Object: Serious violent crimes have recently been committed in Italy by people with legally authorized to bring firearms. Most of these people have eventually been found affected by serious psychological problems and illnesses. A critical review of the administrative procedures aimed at releasing those authorizations is, therefore, deemed as necessary. This study shows a critical review of the scientific literature about the epidemiology of violent behaviours by people with firearms permits, the predictive factors of these conducts and the administrative principles affecting the procedure aimed at issuing those permits. Method: literature was gathered using the on-line Medline and PsychInfo databases, and integrated by paper bibliography. Results: empirical studies and reviews from 1970 on were included. 47 studies about the epidemiology of homicides and suicides committed by people with regular firearms permits and the risk factors that could be detected in these behaviours were included. The researches were subdivided by principal topics: epidemiological studies, stressing factors events and the role of the easy availability of firearms. Conclusions: evaluation of the risk of abuse of firearms is a complex but necessary procedure that involves multiple dimensions: anamnestic, behavioural and intrapsychic. The empirical literature still offers little support to the permit issuing administrative procedures and the most part of the authors find that the risk factors identified do not have a certain predictive value. Nevertheless, a correlation is found with some data from the anamnesis and clinical exams: some violent behaviours, some psychopathological conditions and alcol abuse. Comparing data about violent crimes with data of the spreading of firearms does not confirm the hypothesis that a limited availability of legal firearms could substantially reduce the impact of violent events. Some risk factors could be identified only by more well-constructed procedures than the anamnestic data of psychopathology or medical controls alone that are used nowadays in the administrative permit-issuing procedures. Also considered that these data and control largely depend, under Italian law, on the permit-requerant’s declarations. Considering homicides and suicides by firearms only as a symptom of psychopathology is not wholly effective. It is, instead, important not to restrict this problem only to medical or psychiatric principles. A multidisciplinary psychiatric, psychological and juridical reappraisal is hoped in order to redefine the evaluation procedures and the regulations nowadays in force.[:]
Category: No 3 - September - 2006
Share this article
