Key words: paternalism, rights, psychiatric advance directives, open dialogue, shared decision making, being with
Forty years ago, many people who came out of the Italian asylums could count on the support of mental health professionals, who assumed a role of active protection of the citizenship rights of these people, overshadowing the dimension of the illness. This paternalistic profile (which can be summarized in the formula of “doing for”) has been maintained, very often, also for the people who now access the community services born after the Psychiatric Reform. This profile is increasingly in conflict with the new rights of citizenship, which have been affirmed in the last decade (in particular, with the right to be active subjects in the decisions concerning our health, sanctioned by the recent law on Advance Directives of Treatment).
The paper takes into consideration the complexity of this transition to a “post-paternalistic” psychiatry, which implies a transition from “doing for” to “doing with” (or, better still, “being with”). Some approaches, including Open Dialogue, seem to be able to facilitate this transition towards more democratic practices of full sharing of decisions.
